Our grading philosophy is simple: the condition of the actual DVD matters more than assumptions based on packaging. We grade conservatively and reserve the highest grade for DVDs that show virtually no evidence of use.
Sealed DVDs
A sealed DVD is not necessarily a factory-sealed DVD.
Shrink-wrap and factory-wrap machines are readily available, making it relatively easy for a DVD case to be rewrapped and made to appear unopened. Because of this, we do not consider ordinary shrink-wrap alone to be proof that a DVD is factory sealed or has never been opened.
The seals we consider reliable are identifiable tamper-proof or tamper-evident manufacturer seals that cannot simply be duplicated by rewrapping the case.
Certain releases from Wicked Pictures and Voyeur Media, for example, used distinctive manufacturer seals. These are exceptions rather than the rule.
Our 5-Tier DVD Grading System
Grade 5 — Exceptional Condition
Under a quick inspection, the DVD appears essentially perfect. One or two extremely minor touches may be acceptable, but they must be minimal. Any obvious mark prevents a DVD from receiving a Grade 5.
Grade 4 — Light Use
Some light signs of use or normal handling. Minor marks may be present, but there is no significant or heavy wear.
Grade 3 — Obvious Wear
Shows obvious signs of use and wear. There may be a few areas of heavy wear or scratching, but the heavy wear does not continue around the entire disc.
Grade 2 — Heavily Worn
Serious scratching or wear around most or all of the DVD. Many DVDs that have been loose inside the case for a long period of time fall into this category.
Grade 1 — Poor / Filler Copy
Major scuffs, scratches or other significant damage. The DVD may or may not play. This is essentially a filler copy until a better example can be found.